Why Why Welsh?

This blog was born because, as XKCD states below:

But seriously, I was somewhat tired of responding to the same comments and stories in the press and seeing other Welsh speakers respond to the same comments and stories in the press ad nauseum. Wouldn’t it be better, I thought, to have one website with a list of questions or statements about the Welsh language? Then it could be simply quoted or linked to rather than having to write the same response from scratch every time.

Also, I wrote a post on my blog a few months ago explaining why I send my kids to a Welsh medium school. The post has been extremely popular and has attracted about ten times more hits than the rest of my blog combined. So there’s clearly a quizzical audience out there, and an unmet need for a series of posts that deal with some of the main issues surrounding the language.

I’d like to make it clear that I don’t blame people for their antipathy towards the Welsh language. If I couldn’t speak the language, perhaps I’d feel the same way. Any attention given to the language in the mainstream press tends to focus on the negative. Moreover, speakers of dominant languages the world over tend to hold negative views about the minority languages that exist within their political boundaries. It’s not just an English-Welsh thing – it seems to be human nature.

As I say in this blog, I feel that it’s our responsibility as Welsh speakers to make sure that people understand what the language is actually about.

However, while many Welsh speakers know in their hearts that the language is worth preserving they can’t quite always explain why they feel that way. I was certainly one of them. But as I’ve become older and wiser (well, I am 29) I’ve discovered that there’s more to the survival of the Welsh language than the purely emotional argument I tended to espouse in the past.

I can’t promise that this website provides a definitive answer to any of the questions raised, and I’d appreciate any feedback that you could give. If I’ve piqued your interest, please pursue the work of others who have written about this subject in far greater depth than I have. An excellent starting point would be David Crystal‘s book, Language Death, which is an exhaustive and thorough rebuttal of the argument that the death of any language is a good thing. I’m told Mike Parker’s book Neighbours From Hell is also worth a read if you want further insight into the not-always-cordial relationship between the two languages.

This is just my paltry contribution, which is better than nothing.

Diolch yn fawr.

Ifan Morgan Jones

3 thoughts on “Why Why Welsh?

  1. And then there’s the discussion about being Welsh but not able to speak the language. I went to English medium schooland although my mother started speaking Welsh with me from babyhood, I remember walking away from it t the age of 4 because I never heard it anywhere outside home. I regretted it ever since but have recently had the good fortune to find a way of learning which is painless and ore importantly it works. Now O feel like a speaker who has a lot to learn rather than a beginner and the sense of achievement and pride that gives is immeasurable. Please take this as a very positive plug for the website ‘ Say Something in Welsh. I can’t praise it enough for its methodology and also its inadvertent creation of a true on as well as offline community

Leave a Reply to Steve Roberts Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s